‘She wants him gone’: My friend took in a homeless man as a caretaker. After 10 years, how can she evict him?

Editorial Team·June 30, 2026·Updated: June 30, 2026·3 min read·Source: MarketWatch

TL;DR: A woman confronts the challenge of evicting a caretaker she took in a decade ago. With legal nuances at play, her options are limited.

The Long-Term Arrangement

Ten years ago, a woman opened her home to a homeless man, seeking companionship and help around the house. What started as a gesture of kindness has now become a complex legal dilemma as she wishes to end their living arrangement. The question at hand is: how can she legally evict him after such a long time?

Understanding Tenant Rights

In many jurisdictions, a person who has lived in a residence for an extended period may have acquired certain tenant rights. These rights can complicate eviction processes, especially if the caretaker has been treating the home as his own. In some states, an individual may be considered a tenant if they pay rent, even if informally agreed or if the rent is significantly lesser than the market rate.

In this case, the woman must first assess whether the caretaker has any established rights, which can vary significantly from state to state. Seeking legal counsel could provide clarity on whether a formal rental agreement was ever implied or created over the years.

Ad placeholder

Legal Routes for Eviction

If the woman determines that the caretaker possesses rights as a tenant, she will need to follow legal eviction procedures, which generally include:

Providing Written Notice: Most states require landlords to give tenants written notice before commencing formal eviction proceedings. The notice period can vary, often ranging from 30 to 90 days.
Filing an Eviction Lawsuit: If the caretaker does not vacate the property after receiving notice, the next step is to file an eviction lawsuit in the appropriate court.
Court Hearing: In court, both parties will have the opportunity to present their cases. If the court rules in favor of the woman, a judgment will be issued for eviction.

It’s crucial for the woman to maintain proper documentation of the caretaker's residency, any financial transactions, and her communications regarding the eviction.

Emotional and Financial Considerations

Beyond legal processes, the emotional toll of evicting someone who has been living in your home for a decade can be significant. The woman may need to consider how the eviction process will affect her relationship with the caretaker and whether mediation could be a more amicable solution.

Financially, legal fees associated with eviction proceedings can add up. The woman should prepare for potential court costs and attorney fees as part of the process, emphasizing the need for a well-planned approach. Understanding the potential delays and costs associated with eviction may also affect her timeline and strategy.

Frequently Asked Questions

What if the caretaker refuses to leave?

If the caretaker refuses to leave after receiving proper notice, the woman will need to proceed with legal action. This typically involves filing an eviction lawsuit in the local court.

Can the woman simply change the locks?

Changing the locks without going through the legal eviction process could be considered unlawful eviction. It is important to follow the correct legal procedures to avoid potential legal repercussions.